Joni Menkhoff
Tara Cagle goes above and beyond! She found us fast, and best price auto insurance after we called around to many agencies. She makes the process so smooth. Very knowledgeable and responds quickly!! Highly recommend!! Thank you, Tara!!

Get In Touch
Have questions or ready for a quote? We're here to help, no pressure.
(888) 334-6454
Mon–Fri: 9am – 5pm
Sat: By appointment only
Sun: Closed
We specialize in
We work to provide policies that protect our clients' assets and well-being. Independent agency serving Ohio.
Protect yourself from financial loss in the event of an accident or other covered event.
Protect your home and possessions from natural disasters, theft, and other covered events.
Why Choose Us
We compare top carriers to find the right protection at the right price.
Talk to real people in Ohio, not a call center. We're your neighbors, and we're here for you.
Get competitive quotes in minutes. We do the shopping so you don't have to fill out endless forms.
We compare top Ohio carriers to find coverage that fits your needs and your budget.
Reviews
Real reviews from real Ohio clients on Google.
Joni Menkhoff
Tara Cagle goes above and beyond! She found us fast, and best price auto insurance after we called around to many agencies. She makes the process so smooth. Very knowledgeable and responds quickly!! Highly recommend!! Thank you, Tara!!
Nicole Gee
Tara was so helpful in our process! Made things very easy for us and we are so thankful for her! And the money she helped us save! We would highly recommend going to tara for any of your insurance needs!
William Berndt
We seriously love our insurance specialist's. Jodi and Tarah always go above and beyond for our family 🙏 I hope more families choose you guys to save money! The first time we choose them they saved us $1200 plus a year on car insurance, boat & home owners together
Goliath Mehling
Wasn't sure if writing a review for a friend that has made my insurance process problem free. BUT I can not count how many times I have been around Tara after her working hours and she will get a call, a text or a message about insurance and she ALWAYS excuses her self and handles the issue. That is going above and beyond and why I wrote a review.
Robert Mooney
Where do I even start with this amazing organization! Jody has been my Agent for almost 10 years and I send all my friends and family her way. Don't hesitate, give them a call for " Good Insurance " and a Happy experience.
Cassandra Halbeisen
Lucy Gutierrez has been amazing she checks for better rates every time my policy is up! She got me a better deal with better insurance at a lower cost every time I contact her with a question she responds quickly. I've referred several people to her and everyone who has switched was so glad they did!!! I'd recommend Lucy to anyone looking to for a reliable trustworthy insurance specialist.
Areas We Serve
Insurance Specialists of Ohio helps homeowners and businesses across Fremont, Port Clinton, Perrysburg, Toledo, Sandusky, and the greater Columbus area find affordable auto, home, and commercial insurance. We compare rates from top Ohio carriers so you don't have to, bringing you the right coverage at the right price.













































How Can We Help?